
blog 'success'
I'm going to get serious here for a moment. Most fashion bloggers do what they do with a hell of a lot of passion. I'm no exception to the rule. Since 2008 I've maintained this little slice of cyberspace and loved it intensely (while still accepting that it is, after all, just a blog, of course). I think I'm very fortunate to receive the comments and followers that I do, especially considering that my blog is a bit of a random collection of stuff that doesn't overtly cater to any particular kind of reader and doesn't fulfil the all hallowed 'niché' that is apparently necessary in order to make a blog 'successful'. I look at blogs with 3000 followers and I marvel at that. I do see it as an achievement. It's almost like that blog has become a magazine. People click on it to know something, to find out something, and if that something is the blogger's opinion, that's fucking fantastic. I don't ever feel as though a blog's large following is undeserved or difficult to understand. Some bloggers network harder than others. Some bloggers dedicate more time to replying to comments or engaging the community. Some bloggers are great with giveaways or appealing to what readers want. Some bloggers are fortunate enough to have courted some kind of publicity which led to a massive traffic increase. Some consistently produce amazing outfit photos and some can write like gods on acid. It's all good.
Of course quantity, size, popularity - these are only some of the scales on which to judge success. Some of my favourite blogs have under 50 followers. They are magical little places where the blogger has a zero compromise attitude and doesn't tend to be about the 'polish' or about putting forth a certain image. They offer up their life, their passions, their weird little notions, and that's what sends the shivers up my spine. If I was asked to sum up how best to judge the success of your blog, I'd say it's got a hundred times more to do with how you feel about it every time you log in to post than it has to do with brand attention or the number of followers. If you're not getting a kick out of it and it's not pushing you or inspiring you or helping you to reach the like-minded, it's not successful.
The problem with my kind of attitude is that it riles against a certain reality. A reality I've been faced with more and more as my blog matures.
Blogs are the new darlings of brands.
A union has been made and it's thriving. I think it's caused a lot of bloggers out there to feel that success is some tangible thing that's set in stone and meted out by brands. When they approach you - you've arrived.
keeping your head when all around you ischaos brands
Ever seen this badge on a blog before?
If you click on it you'll see that it's a statement bloggers can choose to make, declaring that their blog is an advert-free space and that they work in accordance with the belief that taking money in exchange for ad space devalues blogging as a medium. This might seem a little extreme to a lot of you. I must admit, I always used to find the notion a little hasty. I mean, what's wrong with making money doing something you love? And, why should we view all brands as 'bad'? But I'm beginning to see the value in this little badge and the approach behind it.
Blogging is young. It's the little sister of journalism and it's done well in pissing off and threatening the traditional fashion literati by proving that you don't need to go to fashion school or work your way up through some hierarchical structure to have your voice heard. It's been revolutionary in that sense, but in order to keep that edge it has to remain impartial and keep some of its journalistic purity. But the most important reason to honour the badge, or at least appreciate its message, is to show brands that we are not going to be told that success equals brand attention or that our ambition for our blog should be for a brand to pluck it from obscurity and give it their corporate seal of approval.
Now that I've had my say, I'm going to make an example of bloggerswardrobe.com
They're approaching fashion bloggers with limited traffic and small-to-medium followings, supposedly giving them an 'opportunity' to audition for a shot at being selected to obtain free clothing from brands. It all looks fantastic at first glance, right? Well, I call bullshit. Look at the bloggers they've already selected for this brand collaboration. They're all very big fish with thousands of followers. Yet, bloggerswardrobe have told thousands of blogs with not even half of that following that if they make an audition video mentioning bloggerswardrobe and get as much traffic as they can to the site, they might be in with a chance of joining the big guns and getting free stuff.
Hundreds of blogs have uploaded videos dedicated to bloggerswardrobe, giving them lots of traffic and publicity. These bloggers are being unknowingly used as pawns. They are not going to be selected unless they have seriously high traffic, yet they're being encouraged to use their blog space to advertise this business. (bloggerswardrobe have not yet confirmed which supposedly amazing brands are taking part in this collaboration, but with the amount of bloggers giving bloggerswardrobe free publicity, it won't take much for them to convince brands that it has clout.) I was approached by bloggerswardrobe, worked out pretty quickly how the scheme was only benefiting them, and this bad publicity is the only publicity they're going to get from me.
I'm not trying to tell others what to do with their space. I'm simply making a point that I don't think can be made enough if you're really serious about your blog:
Don't be a bitch for business.
Don't be a puppy dog. Don't jump at the chance of a free dress without thinking first. Your blog has value to them, but unless you're at the very top of your game in terms of traffic and following, their business does not have value for you. So don't sell yourself short and don't let them continue believing that fashion bloggers are a bunch of dumb onions who don't understand how the system works.
I'm going to get serious here for a moment. Most fashion bloggers do what they do with a hell of a lot of passion. I'm no exception to the rule. Since 2008 I've maintained this little slice of cyberspace and loved it intensely (while still accepting that it is, after all, just a blog, of course). I think I'm very fortunate to receive the comments and followers that I do, especially considering that my blog is a bit of a random collection of stuff that doesn't overtly cater to any particular kind of reader and doesn't fulfil the all hallowed 'niché' that is apparently necessary in order to make a blog 'successful'. I look at blogs with 3000 followers and I marvel at that. I do see it as an achievement. It's almost like that blog has become a magazine. People click on it to know something, to find out something, and if that something is the blogger's opinion, that's fucking fantastic. I don't ever feel as though a blog's large following is undeserved or difficult to understand. Some bloggers network harder than others. Some bloggers dedicate more time to replying to comments or engaging the community. Some bloggers are great with giveaways or appealing to what readers want. Some bloggers are fortunate enough to have courted some kind of publicity which led to a massive traffic increase. Some consistently produce amazing outfit photos and some can write like gods on acid. It's all good.
Of course quantity, size, popularity - these are only some of the scales on which to judge success. Some of my favourite blogs have under 50 followers. They are magical little places where the blogger has a zero compromise attitude and doesn't tend to be about the 'polish' or about putting forth a certain image. They offer up their life, their passions, their weird little notions, and that's what sends the shivers up my spine. If I was asked to sum up how best to judge the success of your blog, I'd say it's got a hundred times more to do with how you feel about it every time you log in to post than it has to do with brand attention or the number of followers. If you're not getting a kick out of it and it's not pushing you or inspiring you or helping you to reach the like-minded, it's not successful.
The problem with my kind of attitude is that it riles against a certain reality. A reality I've been faced with more and more as my blog matures.
Blogs are the new darlings of brands.
A union has been made and it's thriving. I think it's caused a lot of bloggers out there to feel that success is some tangible thing that's set in stone and meted out by brands. When they approach you - you've arrived.
keeping your head when all around you is
Ever seen this badge on a blog before?
If you click on it you'll see that it's a statement bloggers can choose to make, declaring that their blog is an advert-free space and that they work in accordance with the belief that taking money in exchange for ad space devalues blogging as a medium. This might seem a little extreme to a lot of you. I must admit, I always used to find the notion a little hasty. I mean, what's wrong with making money doing something you love? And, why should we view all brands as 'bad'? But I'm beginning to see the value in this little badge and the approach behind it.
Blogging is young. It's the little sister of journalism and it's done well in pissing off and threatening the traditional fashion literati by proving that you don't need to go to fashion school or work your way up through some hierarchical structure to have your voice heard. It's been revolutionary in that sense, but in order to keep that edge it has to remain impartial and keep some of its journalistic purity. But the most important reason to honour the badge, or at least appreciate its message, is to show brands that we are not going to be told that success equals brand attention or that our ambition for our blog should be for a brand to pluck it from obscurity and give it their corporate seal of approval.
Now that I've had my say, I'm going to make an example of bloggerswardrobe.com
They're approaching fashion bloggers with limited traffic and small-to-medium followings, supposedly giving them an 'opportunity' to audition for a shot at being selected to obtain free clothing from brands. It all looks fantastic at first glance, right? Well, I call bullshit. Look at the bloggers they've already selected for this brand collaboration. They're all very big fish with thousands of followers. Yet, bloggerswardrobe have told thousands of blogs with not even half of that following that if they make an audition video mentioning bloggerswardrobe and get as much traffic as they can to the site, they might be in with a chance of joining the big guns and getting free stuff.
Hundreds of blogs have uploaded videos dedicated to bloggerswardrobe, giving them lots of traffic and publicity. These bloggers are being unknowingly used as pawns. They are not going to be selected unless they have seriously high traffic, yet they're being encouraged to use their blog space to advertise this business. (bloggerswardrobe have not yet confirmed which supposedly amazing brands are taking part in this collaboration, but with the amount of bloggers giving bloggerswardrobe free publicity, it won't take much for them to convince brands that it has clout.) I was approached by bloggerswardrobe, worked out pretty quickly how the scheme was only benefiting them, and this bad publicity is the only publicity they're going to get from me.
I'm not trying to tell others what to do with their space. I'm simply making a point that I don't think can be made enough if you're really serious about your blog:
Don't be a bitch for business.
Don't be a puppy dog. Don't jump at the chance of a free dress without thinking first. Your blog has value to them, but unless you're at the very top of your game in terms of traffic and following, their business does not have value for you. So don't sell yourself short and don't let them continue believing that fashion bloggers are a bunch of dumb onions who don't understand how the system works.
34 comments:
Love this post!:) Your have an amazing way of writing and I completely with everything you said.
http://bowtiedbeauty.blogspot.com/
xx
For the first time, I am going to swear on a blog..but I fuckin' love this post..you've said exactly what I think when I see a lot of fashion blogs and company ads on their page, its fine if thats their thing, but I often wonder if its all right and sussed! I like finding the little gems that have no one on their blog, because they have something new. I post what I like, I never think anyone is going to read the stuff I write and for me the moment I stop thinking that is the day I need to stop blogging completely as I'll have been sucked into the whirlpool of bloggerty robots like the rest!! When I see an outfit post, I have no problem with them, as long as the person is wearing what they actually wear..like their own style and personality coming through. I don't really want to see what some store gave you free or whatever brand. Unless its a brand you really love to wear. I like to see the real person's attitude..you get what I mean anyways. I think if one makes money off their blog, it should be done on their own terms, not the one advertising on your blog, and I have many friends who have that problem, they need to get comments, views and what not to make the sponsers or whatever they call them these days happy, which I find nonsense really, but ahh well!! Great post chick, I tip my hat to ya ;)
I love this post! Bloggers, unite! or something like that..
Well, I'll definitely keep it in mind, if I ever get traffic that could attract scetchy, or non-scetchy companies...
Wow, this was really eye opening. I had a blogger leave me a comment asking me to help with traffic to the bloggers wardrobe site. Of course I helped her, I dont mind being supportive but it just seemed like she was so desperate to get into this. I didnt know much about bloggers wardrobe until you explained it, but its awful that they are making bloggers feel validated only through their stamp of approval. But its even more awful that bloggers are being taken in by these people. I wouldnt mind having ads, just as long as its legit. Thanks so much for this post!
xx
Thank you for visiting me. I really love your blog ! He is so interesting.
I love this post.
Want to follow ?
Have a wonderful weekend. x
Amazing post doll! The effort you put in it is visible and very inspiring!
hugs and kisses by Mani.
Thank you so much for this post! Sometimes I am afraid to write of such things... I have less than 50 followers and when I look at other successful blogs I think to myself: why the hell she/he has more followers, this blog isn't worth it, the words are bad, the outfits are bad (and I do realize that you cannot discuss one's taste). And then I realize...
really thought provoking post. ive been blogging for about 4 years now and it's been love hate. love when i have time and building relationships/finding new blogs/seeing things. i started my blog as a means of sorting images and before than i didn't really read many.
i started off reading menswear blogs and big street styles ones then i moved onto more personal fashion/styling blogs and then i found lots of interior and arty blogs. now its a mixture of all 3 but i have canned a lot that didn't really mean anything to me anymore
in terms on integrity you do have to be careful, it's easy to get caught up when suddenly you get all the attention, i've been there. but i'm in a happy situation now, have loyal followers and mate proper friends. i do get free stuff some times but prob more so because there are less male bloggers but i wouldn't say mines a style blog. it's a mix and that's just what i'm into. the wardrobe thing sounds like it will bomb in terms up credibility to me, no one seems to be excited by it. dangerous grounds
I don't do advertising. At all. And I never will.
Reviews of products I genuinely wear and like are one thing. Fairly compensated reviews of products I am given are also fair game. However, I will not put advertisements on the top, bottom, or margins of my blog.
It just isn't what I'm interested in.
Hi there!
You are an amazing writter, you kept me interested the hole post on every word you wrote. And the most important you left me thinking about what i ve just read...
I agreed with you in so many things, I just started blogging and I really enjoy every part of doing it(:
Im glad Ive found your blog, its great(:
thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Hope you re having an awesome day full of inspiration and lemon cookies(;
Carmila Ponycat (pony-cat.blogspot.com)
I really enjoyed this post. I started to blog because i have wanted to be a jounralist all my life. And i found this almost magically free outlet where I can voice my ideas and almost practice being a jounralist. I have realized however that alot of bloggers are only obessed with getting 1 million followers and thats one of the reason i adore ^ Honesty: Probably not much chance I'll reply to comments like, 'COOL! FOLLOW ME! XXX
I have 3 followers and the most comments i have ever gotten is about 15 and i think that is pretty cool. The goal of my blog is to develop my writing skills and expend my skill set. I love just seeing that I've "touched: someone with my writing. Maybe not really touched but at least made them feel something like oh thats pretty cooler. Im not saying i would never take advertising because if i could make this into a career that would be prett amazing. However i will never be taken advantage of like on bloggerswardrobe.com Thanks for being a great writer (wow this is way to long i might have to make my own post from this)
I just wrote 2 comments awkward please post the second one if u post either opps:)
Love this...it's all so true!
xoxo ~ Courtney
http://sartorialsidelines.com
cool blog
http://mrsjuliajulia.blogspot.com/
Such an interesting topic, and I have never really thought about it. Thanks for writing this!
Hey !
This post is awesome, I think you're absolutely right about the bloggerswardrobe, I think this is just a scam, to trick bloggers that want to be famous and to win free stuff.
I don't think it's wrong, to win money out of your blog, after all it's a profession. But if you create a blog just to win money, it will never work, if you don't love what you do, nothing is going to happen.
Xoxo
lovely post!
I love your blog!
xx
www.fashionapp.blogspot.com
www.fashionapp.blogspot.com
Looks like you really hit on something bloggers are passionate about in this post. Advertising and success are not mutually exclusive, I agree. I think that the choice to advertise or not is definitely a personal one. Thanks for bringing to light something that might be confusing to a lot of people.
XOXO
Guys, thanks so much for your comments on this post.
Just to clarify, there is no way that I'm saying I'm staunchly anti-advertising on blogs or that I'd never consider getting involved with a brand I believed in and felt I could collaborate with in a good way. I think the article is my attempt to draw attention at getting involved with brands without thinking it through, without knowing your rights and without understanding what value your blog has to businesses looking to make a profit. But the real point that I hope I managed to get across is that brand attention isn't something you need to strive for in order to prove to yourself or others that your blog is good.
Kelly-Ann,
Absolutely. I think each blogger needs to come to their own decisions about what kind of "advertising" they wish to allow.
A number of REALLY good posts have come out on this subject this past week. I made the decision back in February when I started getting a bit more notice (although this month has been the busiest on record with a quite a few unsolicited blogrolling, which I am grateful for, and some interesting email conversations) that I would not have advertising on my blog in the form of permanent ad placement, but that I would accept items for review (in return for fair compensation, full editorial control, and FTC disclosure, of course). That's definitely a form of "advertising" for the companies, but of a far different form than the panel ads in the margins. I simply do not feel comfortable with that kind of permanent advertising.
I do think too few bloggers, especially right at the beginning of increasing exposure, ask themselves what their goals are and what they will allow. They get wrapped up in at all. For me, I have a job, and I love my job, and blogging is not my job, so I have neither the time nor the inclination to turn brands into advertising clients. One-off posts of items I'd buy anyway? That I can do. It fits the goal of my blog as a hobby and won't interfere in my job.
Really insightful post! I've been approached by a few companies lately who seem to expect me to jump at the chance to pimp them for free (or in exchange for "exposure"). I'll admit I was tempted for a bit, but came to the conclusion that unless it's a company I'm truly excited about - no thanks.
Anyway, thanks again for posting this - it sums up some of my own feelings on blogging lately, and it's nice to hear some likeminded voices!
Your point is valueble for me. Thanks!
My blog:
DSL Anbieter dslvergleichdsl.com
All I can say is BRAVO! <3
You write like a "god on acid" my dear!
I applaud you for this! You have said everything that i have been wanting to say since i started blogging and was approached by blogger wardrobe! I am so glad i am not an onion and realised this from the outset too!
It makes me feel physically sick to see all my favourite little blogs writing posts for bloggers wardrobe and seriously believing that they may be in with a chance! It just makes them look so stupid and powerless!
I do have an advert on my site but it is for a brand i love and would have it there what ever. I hate the direction the blog world seems to be taking with all this! I must admit i have been sucked into the 'need brands to pick my blog up' before but have realised how unhappy this has made me recently! I now know to stick to my morals and blog for me again and the community of friends i have made!
Keep up the great work girl!!
x
Jess
SparksandFireworks.blogspot
I normally don't read such long posts but I read every single word you wrote! I agree with some points you make completely! Especially with what you say about bloggerswardrobe. Anyways, I don't think that collaborating with brands necessarily makes a blogger dependable or less objective. I think it's a matter of personality, there are some great bloggers out there that collaborate with brands and are still really opinionated :) Great post!
I am so excited to be hosting my first giveaway! Check it out here: http://fashion-thrill.blogspot.com/2011/08/my-first-giveaway.html
XoXo
Plami
http://fashion-thrill.blogspot.com/
"If I was asked to sum up how best to judge the success of your blog, I'd say it's got a hundred times more to do with how you feel about it every time you log in to post than it has to do with brand attention or the number of followers."
Thank you. Thank you so much. I needed to hear this today. I started my blog a week ago, and every day I post something new, I consistently get at least 80 hits. Today, I had a new post, and I got 35. I was feeling down on myself until I saw this quote, because I LOVE my blog. Love it like it's my tiny, puny web child with a runny nose and mismatched socks. I know this wasn't the main theme of your post today, and I know this comment is now becoming a novel, but I just cannot tell you how much I appreciate that quote. I'm now going to follow you on Twitter. And staple that quote to my head so I remember it every time I get even a little down about my beautiful baby blog. :)
OH MY GOD THANK YOU.
Especially to the part about bloggerswardrobe.com That shit has been pissing me for the longest time. I've had a draft saved about them but, honestly, I didn't want to the only blogger that thought it was a load of crap. The biggest reason it bothers me is because they claim they're going to help bloggers maintain their integrity when they accomplish the exact opposite.
And I'VE BEEN SEEING THEM ON EVERY BLOG EVER (Except for the blog giants that can be selective). It's so absolutely sad. I can't wait to meet the makers of that website. They're probably two or three frumpy men thinking they have found the next profit faucet.
Oh well....
Great post! You write amazingly - kind of like a god on acid :)
congrats on making it to the IFB links a la mode.
Freakin' loved this post and everything you have said here. Yes it's a long and wordy post, but every word counted and got my attention.
Every blogger should be aware of the bigger picture behind partnering with a company/advertising etc... Whether or not there are freebies involved.
I recently read Vahni's post about the perks and pitfalls...
http://www.gritandglamour.com/2011/08/08/the-perks-and-pitfalls/
Anyhoos, have yourself a top weekend.
x.o.x.o
I suppose I'm one of those 'dumb onions' for putting up a vid about bloggerswardrobe? Well they don't choose just anyone you know, there are loads of blogs that haven't been chosen to try out.
in response to anon: I think the tone of this article towards bloggers who've chosen to participate in the auditions is sympathetic, and if it didn't come across that way I can only apologise.
My belief is that it's obvious enough that Bloggers Wardrobe have targeted a high number of what I'd call 'middling' blogs (like mine), knowing that inclusion into the project to receive freebies and invitations will not be a possibility. Logically, that means that Bloggers Wardrobe have simply come up with a great way to generate traffic and interest without having to give anything to the bloggers in return. They are by no means the only company around who've tuned in to this kind of publicity technique. Cyberspace is overflowing with companies who understand the power of the blogging community to spread a message or generate interest and if they can tap into that without having to offer any payment, by dangling the glass carrot of possible free clothes in front of us for example, they'll do it.
This isn't intended to be anti-brands. I actually have links in my sidebar to support ethical clothing companies because that's where my heart lies. In the future I wouldn't just turn my nose up at any business that came along. But I'd think it through seriously and make sure I was getting as much out of it as they were before accepting any offer. That's my only point.
My advice to you, if you've posted a video promoting Bloggers Wardrobe and you have under 1000 followers, is to remove it and don't have anything else to do with them. In my opinion, they're using you.
Also, check this link out:
http://connect.icrossing.co.uk/blogger-backlash-bloggers-wardrobe_6818
It seems the bloggers who are already on board are not happy with the company's ethics either.
My case is the opposite, I own a small boutique and tried handing a few samples to bloggers I like.
Now I'm bombarded with emails from fashion bloggers asking for sponsorship. Most of them only have reviews (of free stuff) on their blogs.
I got a bit discouraged after that. :(
I am not a "Fashionista" and I have never heard of "Bloggerswardrobe" - I so agree with the valuable point you've made above in your post. I blog about what interest me and what I find fanciable.
I do not advertise nor do I have "Google ads" on my page. A number of magazines have interviewed me and have mentioned my blog but that's about it for advertising. lol.
I have yet to do "Giveaways" - but this might change soon or it might remain just as is;-)
This is an excellent article! Please tell me its been published!
x Aliya
www.papermoonsandmacarons.blogspot.com
Post a Comment